Lose It vs MyFitnessPal vs Amy — 2026 Comparison
Lose It vs MyFitnessPal vs Amy Food Journal compared on logging, free vs paid features, pricing, and integrations. See which calorie tracker wins.
Amy Food Journal Team
Updated
Lose It, MyFitnessPal and Amy Food Journal each approach calorie tracking differently. Lose It and MyFitnessPal are database-first trackers with free plans; both now put barcode scanning, photo logging and voice logging in their paid tiers. Amy Food Journal is a paid iPhone app where you type, say or photograph what you ate and it estimates the calories and macros for you to check. Amy costs $9.99/month or $99.99/year in the US after a free 3-day trial. If entering each food one by one is what made you quit before, Amy’s approach is the one to try. If you want a free plan or Android, look at Lose It or MyFitnessPal.
How this comparison was checked: feature and plan details come from each app’s current US App Store listing and help center, checked on October 27, 2026. We did not run timed or accuracy tests of these apps, so this page does not give per-meal timings or accuracy percentages. Plans and prices vary by country, plan length and account.
At-a-Glance Comparison Table
| Feature | Lose It! | MyFitnessPal | Amy Food Journal |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary input | Database search | Database search | Text, voice, photo, barcode and menu scan |
| Food database | 56M+ items and recipes (App Store listing) | 20.5M+ foods (App Store listing) | AI estimates, plus barcode lookups |
| Barcode scanning | Premium (moving; varies by account) | Premium | Included |
| Photo logging | Premium | Premium (Meal Scan) | Included |
| Voice logging | Premium (AI Voice) | Premium | Included |
| Macro tracking | Premium (advanced tracking) | Viewing free; more controls in Premium | Included |
| Apple Health sync | Yes (all iOS users) | Yes | Yes |
| Other device syncs | Fitbit, Garmin, Withings, Google Fit and more (Premium) | 40+ apps and devices | Apple Health only |
| Community | Friends and groups | Community features | None |
| Platforms | iOS, Android, web | iOS, Android, web | iPhone, iPad, Apple Watch (no Android or web) |
| Free plan | Yes | Yes | No (3-day free trial) |
| Paid price (US) | Several Premium options; varies by offer | $19.99/mo or $79.99/yr | $9.99/mo or $99.99/yr |
Sources: Lose It US App Store listing, Lose It’s scanner-transition notice and Apple Health page, MyFitnessPal’s plan comparison and US App Store listing, and Amy’s App Store listing.
How Each App Approaches Calorie Tracking
The biggest difference between these apps isn’t the feature list. It’s how you get a meal into the diary. That matters because the best app is the one you keep using. In the Weight Loss Maintenance trial (Hollis et al., American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 2008; 1,685 adults), keeping food records was among the behaviors most strongly associated with weight loss. That is an association within a coached program, not proof that any app causes weight loss, but it is a good reason to pick the app you’ll actually use.
Lose It: The Familiar Free Starting Point
Lose It has been around since 2008. Its free plan covers calorie tracking for food and exercise, a weight-loss plan and community support, according to its US App Store listing. The same listing puts the barcode scanner, photo meal logging, AI voice logging, advanced tracking (including macros), meal planning and fitness-app syncs under Premium.
The free workflow is the traditional one: search for a food, select an entry, adjust the serving size and log it. For a mixed meal you repeat that for each part.
MyFitnessPal: The Large Connected Platform
MyFitnessPal is the most recognized name in calorie tracking. Its US App Store listing advertises more than 20.5 million foods and connections to more than 40 fitness apps and devices. Its plan comparison keeps food and exercise logging, recipes, macro viewing and percentage-based goals free, and puts barcode scanning, Meal Scan photo logging and voice logging in Premium ($19.99/month or $79.99/year in the US).
MyFitnessPal’s database includes user-submitted entries alongside checked ones, so it’s worth choosing entries with a check mark and confirming the serving size. Our MyFitnessPal review covers the current free and Premium split in detail.
Amy Food Journal: The Write-It-Down Approach
Amy Food Journal changes the logging step. Instead of searching a database, you write what you ate the way you’d text a friend: “two eggs scrambled with cheddar and a slice of sourdough toast.” Amy estimates each item and returns calories and macros for you to confirm or adjust. You can also say the meal, take a photo, scan a barcode or scan a menu, and log from an Apple Watch.
The trade-offs are real. Amy runs on iPhone, iPad and Apple Watch, has no Android or web app and no community features, and syncs with Apple Health rather than directly with Fitbit, Garmin or Samsung Health. If you need any of those, Amy isn’t the right fit. If you mainly want to track your macros with less typing and searching, it’s worth a try.
Amy Food Journal costs $9.99/month or $99.99/year after a free 3-day trial. There is no free plan, and every feature is included with no ads.
Food Database Accuracy: Who Gets the Numbers Right?
Accuracy matters more than database size: a large database doesn’t help if the entry you pick is wrong. We have not run an accuracy test of these three apps, and we have not found an independent study comparing their current accuracy, so we don’t rank them on it.
What we can say is how each app gets its numbers. Lose It and MyFitnessPal draw on large food databases that mix sources, so the quality of an entry varies; favor entries that match the package label or a trusted reference, and check serving sizes. For restaurant lookups, our calorie guides for Starbucks, Chipotle, Chick-fil-A and Dunkin’ are built from each chain’s published nutrition.
Amy Food Journal estimates nutrition from your description, photo or barcode. The more specific you are, the better the estimate: “6 oz grilled chicken breast with 1 cup brown rice” gives it far more to work with than “some chicken and rice.” Read more about how AI calorie counting accuracy works and why calorie numbers differ between apps.
For weight loss, perfect accuracy isn’t required. Consistent logging and watching your weight trend over a few weeks will tell you whether your target is working.
Logging Effort: The Factor That Decides Whether You’ll Stick With It
Most comparisons focus on features and price. But how much effort it takes to log a meal is often what decides whether people keep going.
Lose It’s and MyFitnessPal’s free plans both use the search-select-adjust workflow: type a food name, choose an entry, set the serving size and confirm, once for each part of the meal. Recent and saved foods help with meals you repeat. Both apps now charge for the shortcuts (barcode, photo and voice).
Amy Food Journal collapses that into one step. Type “big mac with medium fries and a diet coke,” and Amy estimates the full meal for you to check and log. We have not timed these apps side by side, so we don’t claim a specific saving, but for mixed meals there are simply fewer steps.
If you’ve tried calorie tracking before and quit because it felt like a chore, that difference is the one to test. Amy Food Journal has a free 3-day trial.
Pricing Breakdown: What You Actually Pay
Price alone doesn’t tell you much. What matters is what each plan includes.
Lose It has a free plan for calorie tracking, a weight-loss plan and community support. Its US App Store listing puts the barcode scanner, photo and voice logging, advanced tracking including macros, meal planning and fitness-app syncs in Premium, and lists several Premium purchase options. Prices vary by region and offer, so check your own App Store. For other free options, see our guide to free calorie tracking apps with no subscription.
MyFitnessPal keeps logging, recipes and macro viewing free. Barcode scanning, Meal Scan, voice logging and ad-free use need Premium, which costs $19.99/month or $79.99/year in the US.
Amy Food Journal has no free plan beyond the 3-day trial. After that it’s $9.99/month or $99.99/year in the US. Every feature is included: text, voice and photo logging, barcode and menu scanning, macros, Apple Health sync, widgets, saved meals and the Apple Watch app.
| Plan | Lose It! | MyFitnessPal | Amy Food Journal |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free | Calorie tracking, weight plan, community | Logging, recipes, macro viewing | 3-day trial only |
| Paid (US) | Several Premium options; varies by offer | $19.99/mo or $79.99/yr | $9.99/mo or $99.99/yr |
| What paid adds | Barcode, photo, AI voice, macros, meal plans, device syncs | Barcode, Meal Scan, voice, ad-free | N/A (all features included) |
Wearable and Third-Party Integrations
If you use an Apple Watch, Fitbit, Garmin or other wearable, integrations might decide it for you. This is where Amy Food Journal is most limited.
MyFitnessPal advertises connections to more than 40 fitness apps and devices, which makes it the broadest of the three.
Lose It’s US listing names Fitbit, Garmin, Withings scales and Google Fit among its fitness-app and device syncs, listed under Premium. Its help center says Apple Health syncing is available to all iOS users.
Amy Food Journal syncs with Apple Health: it can send calories, macros, micronutrients and water, and read burned calories, steps and workouts. It also has its own Apple Watch app for logging by voice or saved meal. It doesn’t connect directly to Fitbit, Garmin or Samsung Health.
For calorie tracking alongside Apple Watch data, all three apps connect through Apple Health.
Privacy and Data Practices
Health data is sensitive, so read each app’s privacy policy and the App Privacy section of its App Store listing before you sign up. MyFitnessPal disclosed a data breach affecting about 150 million accounts in 2018.
Amy Food Journal stores your account and journal in the cloud so it syncs across devices. Its privacy policy says AI services receive only what’s needed to work out your food’s nutrition, Apple Health data is shared only if you turn on sync, your journal isn’t used to sell ads, and your personal information is never sold. You can export your data or delete your account from Settings.
Who Should Choose Each App
Choosing between these three apps isn’t about which is “best” in the abstract. It’s about how you like to log, what devices you use, and what made you quit tracking in the past.
Choose Lose It if you want a familiar free starting point
Lose It is a good pick if you want a simple calorie budget and diary without paying, on iPhone, Android or the web. It’s an easy start for calorie counting beginners. Don’t choose it for free barcode scanning, photo logging or macro targets: the current US listing puts those in Premium.
Choose MyFitnessPal if you want the largest connected platform
MyFitnessPal makes sense if you’re already using it or rely on many connected fitness apps and devices. Its free plan still covers logging, recipes and macro viewing. Barcode scanning, Meal Scan and voice logging need Premium. If you’re shopping for a MyFitnessPal alternative, that paywall is probably why.
Choose Amy Food Journal if searching for every food is what stopped you
Amy Food Journal is for people who quit because logging felt like data entry. Write “burrito bowl with chicken, rice, black beans, salsa and sour cream,” and Amy estimates the whole meal for you to check. The trade-offs are real: no Android, no web app, no community and no direct integrations beyond Apple Health. Try Amy Food Journal’s 3-day free trial to see whether it changes your consistency.
The Research on What Actually Drives Tracking Success
It’s worth stepping back from features to look at the evidence. The science behind food journaling points the same way: recording what you eat is consistently associated with better weight-loss results.
Kaiser Permanente’s summary of the 2008 trial quoted lead author Jack Hollis: “Those who kept daily food records lost twice as much weight as those who kept no records.” A later study in Obesity (Harvey et al., 2019; 142 adults in a 24-week online program) found that time spent logging fell from about 23 minutes a day in the first month to about 15 minutes by month six, and that participants who lost at least 5% or 10% of their weight logged more often each day than those who lost less. Both are associations within structured programs, not proof that a particular app causes weight loss.
The practical takeaway: choose the app you’ll open several times a day. If Lose It’s interface keeps you logging, use Lose It. If writing a meal in one sentence makes you more likely to log every snack, Amy Food Journal is worth trying.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which app is best for losing weight — Lose It, MyFitnessPal, or Amy Food Journal?
Any of them can support weight loss if you use it consistently. Research links keeping food records with greater weight loss, so the best choice is the app you’ll actually use every day. Lose It and MyFitnessPal let you start for free; Amy Food Journal is for people who’d rather write or photograph a meal than search for each food. Use our calorie deficit calculator to find your target before you start.
Is Amy Food Journal free?
No. Amy Food Journal costs $9.99/month or $99.99/year in the US after a free 3-day trial. There is no permanent free plan, but every feature is included in the subscription, with no ads. For genuinely free calorie tracking apps, see our dedicated guide.
How accurate is Amy Food Journal’s AI calorie estimation?
It depends on what you give it. Specific descriptions (“6 oz grilled chicken breast with 1 cup brown rice”) produce better estimates than vague ones (“some chicken and rice”), and you can confirm or adjust every estimate before it’s logged. We have not run a controlled accuracy test, so we don’t publish an accuracy percentage. See our guides on AI calorie counter accuracy and making AI estimates more accurate.
Can I switch from MyFitnessPal to Lose It or Amy Food Journal without losing my data?
Don’t count on a direct import between apps. Export what you want to keep from your old app first. In practice, your recent eating patterns and calorie target matter more than old logs, so starting fresh is usually fine.
Why doesn’t Amy Food Journal have a free tier?
Every meal you log in Amy is estimated by AI, which has a real cost per entry, unlike a database lookup. The subscription pays for that. The 3-day free trial lets you decide whether it’s worth it for you.
Which app has the best barcode scanner?
Barcode scanning is included in Amy Food Journal’s subscription. MyFitnessPal puts barcode scanning in Premium, and Lose It’s US App Store listing puts its Barcode Scanner under Premium, with access differing by account during the transition. We haven’t tested scanner accuracy, so we don’t rank them.
Is MyFitnessPal worth paying for in 2026?
MyFitnessPal Premium ($19.99/month or $79.99/year in the US) makes sense if you’re already invested in it, with years of logs, saved foods and connected apps, and you want barcode scanning, Meal Scan or voice logging. If you’re starting fresh, compare its free plan with Lose It’s and with Amy Food Journal’s trial. Our Noom alternatives guide covers more options.
Which app is best for tracking macros?
All three show protein, carbs and fat. MyFitnessPal keeps macro viewing and percentage-based goals free. Lose It’s US listing puts advanced tracking, including macros, under Premium. Amy Food Journal shows macros for every logged meal. For setting targets, see our how to track macros guide.
Does Amy Food Journal work with Android?
No. Amy Food Journal runs on iPhone, iPad and Apple Watch. Macs with Apple silicon (M1 or later, macOS 15.6+) can run the iPad version, which Apple lists as “Not verified for macOS,” so it is not a native Mac app. There is no Android or web app. On Android, Lose It and MyFitnessPal are the familiar choices. Our best food journal apps roundup lists more options.
Which app is best if I’ve tried calorie tracking before and quit?
If you quit because searching for every food took too long, try Amy Food Journal, which lets you write or photograph a whole meal at once. If you quit because the app felt too complex, Lose It’s free diary is simple. If you want social accountability, both Lose It and MyFitnessPal have community features. See also our Noom alternatives and best food journal apps.
How do these apps compare to Cronometer?
Cronometer is the nutrient-detail specialist: its free plan includes calories, macros and micronutrients, barcode scanning and recipes, according to its Gold page. If vitamins and minerals matter to you, it’s worth a look. See our Cronometer comparison for a detailed side-by-side.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical or nutritional advice. Consult a registered dietitian or healthcare provider before making significant changes to your diet. Calorie tracking apps are tools to support your goals — they are not substitutes for professional guidance.
Keep Reading
All articlesReviews
Lose It! App Review: Still Worth It? (2026)
Honest Lose It! app review covering features, pricing, free vs premium, and how it compares to MyFitnessPal and newer alternatives.
Comparisons
Amy vs MyFitnessPal (2026): Which Calorie Tracker Fits You?
Compare Amy and MyFitnessPal on logging style, price, platforms, AI tools, integrations, and accuracy. Plus alternatives for free and micronutrient tracking.
Guides
Why People Quit MyFitnessPal (And What To Use Instead)
MyFitnessPal is still powerful, but many people leave because daily logging feels heavy. Here is what breaks down, what to try instead, and when to keep using it.
Comparisons
Text vs Photo Calorie Tracking: Which One Works Better?
Text vs photo calorie tracking compared by meal type, accuracy, friction, and real-life use. Learn when to type, scan, photograph, or use a recipe calculator.